The Atkins Diet - Who's Kidding Who

Armen Hareyan's picture

The Atkins Diet after more than thirty years of leading people to believe they could safely eat all the meat, cheese and butter they want, are now trying to shift their position claiming to be misunderstood.

Advertisement

The Atkins Diet after more than thirty years of leading people to believe they could safely eat all the meat, cheese and butter they want, are now trying to shift their position claiming to be misunderstood.

Atkins Diet and Saturated Fat

Responding to ever more growing criticism from scientists, the Atkins Director of Research and Education, Collette Heimowitz, claims she's been telling health professionals in seminars for years that only 20% of a dieter's total calories should come from saturated fat. However, a 20% saturated fat limit was never mentioned in Atkins' books or on the website.

In fact, Heimowitz has done nothing but promote the unlimited use of saturated fat. For example, in a recent article on the Atkins website called "Big Fat Lies," she said, "Saturated fat has gotten a bad rap. You can enjoy the rich, satisfying tastes and textures of saturated fats in the form of cream, butter and meat without health concerns, as long as you're on a controlled carb diet." What happened to the 20% limitation?

Advertisement

"Trying to tell consumers to do math is futile," she said. Does this mean she thinks dieters are stupid? Certainly most people could have understood, if they had at least been advised to eat mostly broiled fish, skinless chicken and lean meat. But that never happened either.

No matter how much Heimowitz and other Atkins promoters try to reposition themselves, their diet is still an unhealthy plan. Responsible scientists, as a protection against heart disease and cancer, recommend keeping saturated fats down to 10% (or less) of total calories. For the Atkins people to try an about-face now, after over thirty years of saying otherwise, is way "too little, too late."

The Professor of Cardiovascular Disease at Harvard University's School of Public Health, Dr. Frank Sacks, responded to the latest Atkins defense. "What they're saying is ridiculous," he said. "It has nothing to do with science; it has all to do with public relations and politics."

Written by Moss Green the Nutrition Host at Bellaonline.

This page is updated on May 18, 2013

Share this content.

If you liked this article and think it may help your friends, consider sharing or tweeting it to your followers.
Advertisement